SAN FRANCISCO – With its stockpile and more lawsuit, Monsanto expected Tuesday to press over with a nationwide legal defense…
SAN FRANCISCO – With its stockpile and more lawsuit, Monsanto expected Tuesday to press over with a nationwide legal defense of the best-selling weed killer Roundup after a San Francisco judge maintained a verdict alleging that it causes cancer.
Legal experts said that the decision will get some value in the courtroom across the country where similar cases await, but it probably leads to more moods. Similar trials doubled from 4000 to 8000 after a jury in San Francisco awarded DeWayne Johnson landslide $ 389 million in August.
Monsanto lawyers said they will fight Johnson and all other trials in the country claiming that the active ingredient in the world’s most popular herbicide – glyphosate – causes cancer. Johnson’s trial was the first trial to go to trial, and several seem ready to start early next year.
Judge Suzanne Bolanos lowered the jury’s award for Johnson to $ 78 million on Monday, but enforced his verdict against St. John. Louis-based Monsanto.
She reduced punishment damages from $ 250 million to $ 39 million in a brief decision that was in stark contrast to an earlier preliminary ruling that she doubted that Johnson would get such a price.
Bolanos said earlier that Johnson’s lawyers failed to show Monsanto executives acting on evil, which is required for punishment. She did not explain her mind change. Several jury members wrote to the judge and asked her to respect her sentence, but legal experts said it should not have affected the judge.
Monsanto lawyer said it would appeal against the decision if Johnson accepts the price instead of asking for a new trial. He has until 7 December to decide.
Monsanto argues that many scientific studies and the United States Environmental Protection Agency have found glyphosate to be safe.
“Because of this we will continue to strongly defend our glyphosate-based products
Legal experts say that the San Francisco decision will not have any immediate legal effect on the other trials, especially as they predict months – if not years –
A court order in San Francisco is also not binding in any other court. California appeals court decisions are binding in California courts, but not on state court action elsewhere.
“It’s only an early piece in a big legal puzzle, “said University of California, Hastings lawyer David Levine.
Levine said the company will not consider resolving any trial until sufficient decision-making is taken against it.” There are just not enough data points to make a decision, “he said.
The German company Bayer Ag bought St. Louis-based Monsanto in August for 63 billion dollars. The stock price fell 8.6 percent per share Tuesday.
“This is clear that this topic will not go,” said UBS analyst Michael Leuchten in a comment to investors Tuesday.
Copyright 2018 Associated Press. This material may not be published, sent, rewritten or redistributed.